Although it's not as sexy as A16, as trendy as Delfina, nor as pedigreed as Quince, Incanto may be the most innovative and inspired of San Francisco's many Italian trattorias.
Tucked away on the outskirts of Noe Valley, Incanto suffers from being off many restaurant patron's radar screens. It bears the unfortunate distinction of being the southernmost restaurant within the San Francisco city limits on the Chronicle's list of the Top 100 restaurants in the Bay Area.
A few years back, the owner, Mark Pastore, took the small fortune he made in the software industry and bought a dilapidated old German restaurant at the corner of Church and Duncan Streets. He stripped it down to its frame and spared no expense to lovingly convert it into the type of rustic trattoria that dots the Tuscan countryside. The dining room is awash in neutral Al Gore earth tones, from the stone pavers beneath your feet to the antiqued brick and stucco walls. Through a set of monastic arches, you have a clear view of the bar area and a glimpse into the buzzing activity in the kitchen.
The food that comes out of that kitchen is what draws me to Incanto again and again. The chef is Chris Cosentino, an iconoclast sporting spiky bleached hair, a goatee, and thick-rimmed Elvis Costello glasses. Although foolishly never tagged as a Rising Star by the Chronicle, Chris creates some of the most interesting food in the city. His daily changing menus take the concept of sustainability seriously - perhaps even more so than Chez Panisse. For one, he and Mark have worked together to make Incanto the first and only restaurant in California to receive "Certified Humane" certification. What really sets Chris - and Incanto - apart from the crowd, however, is his refusal to let any part of the animal go to waste.
Like his hero British chef Fergus Henderson, every night Chris features one or two dishes made from the innards, extremities and other odd cuts of meat that most chefs ignore. Two years ago, he began what has become an annual tradition, "Dining Head to Tail," in which every course features something from the "fifth quarter." I missed the first two events, but others - including Nancy Oakes, Mario Batali, and Fergus Henderson himself - have enjoyed menus that in the past even included a chocolate pudding thickened with pig's blood! Our own local bloggers, the BunRabs, were in attendance last year and shared - in their inimitable witty style - their experience and photos in their review titled "No Guts, No Glory."
I've already made my reservations for the next "Dining Head to Tail" dinner, which takes place in a few weeks on Monday, March 6. The tentative 5-course menu includes the following for $60:
- Beef heart tartare puttanesca
- Marin mountain oysters with pancetta afumicata and capers
- Finanziera, Piemontese market stew of cockscombs, sweetbreads, and sanguinaccio
- Spring lamb trio with spicy lentils, lemon and mint
- Suet pudding with chocolate blood gelato
{Gee, who knew their were oysters in the mountains of Marin! Gosh, do you think he meant "chocolate blood orange gelato"?}
On my most recent visit to Incanto a week or two ago, I thoroughly enjoyed my meal, which although relatively more prosaic was no less delicious. I started with local sardines (now you know the true reason I like this place) that had been lightly cured ceviche-style and were served with a salad of bitter curly-leafed puntarella and radishes.

Next I lapped up every bit of my flavorful seafood stew, in which every one of the clams, mussels, squid and head-on shrimp were as perfectly tender as their counterparts found in Spain and Italy. That favorable comparison is the highest compliment I can pay any seafood preparation in California, where I've found even the best restaurants sadly tend to overcook fish and shellfish.

For dessert, I was lured in by the combination of cardamom pastry cream, kumquats, and chocolate sauce in a napolean-like puff pastry creation. Although it didn't quite live up to my expectations, it was not bad.

Incanto's beverage service is as innovative and concerned with sustainability as the food. Mark, the owner, offers his
guests complimentary local Hetch Hetchy water
that has been filtered and, if desired, carbonated in order to reduce
the number of bottles in landfills and recycling
bins. The restaurant also offers all the wines on the excellent all-Italian wine list by the full- and half-glass. To help educate people less familiar with Italian wines, Mark cleverly places around the base of each glass a cardboard ring inscribed with the producer's name and the wine's region and vintage. Various wine flights are also on offer.
There are more clever touches and innovative approaches at Incanto that you can read about on their website here. I've said enough. Go to Incanto! Support this caring and wonderful little trattoria. Make the trek southward to Noe Valley, especially during the weekdays, which are less busy than they ought to be.
Perhaps I'll bump into some of you at the "Dining Head to Tail" meal on March 6?
Incanto
1550 Church St.
San Francisco
415-641-4500
Food|and Drink|Restaurants|Italian|San Francisco